Empty Benches in Marble Halls: On the Founding of Stanford
LinkedIn ·
I studied abroad at Stanford's Florence campus at Palazzo Capponi and somehow never learned that Leland Stanford Jr. died in Florence. He fell ill on a family tour of Europe and died of typhoid at the Hotel Bristol on March 13, 1884, not yet 16. In 1907 a group of Stanford students had a memorial plaque set into the hotel's wall, where, per Oscar Lewis, it "has since been read by thousands of uncomprehending natives and tourists." Count me among the uncomprehending.
I've been reading Lewis's The Big Four (1938), his history of the four men behind the Central Pacific Railroad (+ Theodore Judah, the engineer who planned the route over the Sierra), and the chapter on Stanford's founding has more in it than I expected. A few parts of the story explain the university, and the region that grew up around it, better than anything I heard on campus.
A school for building things
Five weeks after their son's death, Jane and Leland Stanford rewrote their wills in Paris to endow a memorial. They first considered a museum, then settled on a technical school, a decision Lewis says was "probably influenced by Stanford's admiration for mechanical ingenuity in any form." The examples are wonderful. He once spent half a day studying a medieval catapult in a Paris museum. His castle visits ran long because he wanted to see how the drawbridges worked & how the moats were filled and drained. In the late 1860s he insisted the Central Pacific use newfangled compressed air drills on the Summit Tunnel, a fight that nearly split the partnership. He bankrolled Muybridge's photographs of a horse in motion (the cover image is one of them, shot on his Palo Alto track in 1878, w/ "owned by Leland Stanford" right in the caption), and at home his favorite thing to show guests was a set of mechanical birds that opened their tin beaks and sang when he pressed a hidden button.
The technical school eventually grew into a university, but the bias survived. Touring Eastern schools in 1886, the Stanfords came away from MIT and Cornell impressed anew w/ the value of the applied sciences. When Stanford later recruited David Starr Jordan as president, he described a university where students would be "trained for usefulness in life." Stanford is known today for building things rather than only theorizing about them, and that trait goes back to the founding brief.
The Berkeley that wasn't
The most surprising part is that Stanford's school almost became part of the University of California, Berkeley. While plans were still taking shape, he considered folding his technical school into the state university, and he had the Governor appoint him to its board of regents. He attended several meetings. Then the state legislature refused to confirm the appointment, which Lewis calls "a severe blow to his dignity," and that ended any chance of joining forces (I come from a long line of Cal Bears - my sister is a fourth-generation Berkeley grad). When Stanford later laid out his terms to Jordan, one stood out: the new university was to be free from political control, "in particular from meddling at the hands of the California legislature."
Folly
The plan was announced in the summer of 1886, and outside California it was treated as a joke. Berkeley had fewer than 300 students after years of operation, which critics took as proof there was no need for another college less than 40 miles away. One prediction held that Stanford's professors would "lecture to empty benches in marble halls." An Eastern editor wrote that there was "about as much need for a new university in California as for an asylum of decayed sea captains in Switzerland."
The university opened in October 1891 to 415 students, a young man from Oregon named Herbert Hoover among them. Less than a generation later, Stanford was struggling to keep enrollment down, and by the time Lewis was writing, Berkeley had grown from 300 students to 18,000. The critics measured demand for something new by counting the users of what already existed. Skeptics make that mistake with almost every new technology, because current usage is the only data they have, and the demand that matters (often called latent demand) hasn't shown up yet.
Life on the frontier
Critics have always said what's dreamed in California can never be built. The pattern repeats in nearly every technology cycle, and I think it's simply the cost of living on the frontier, where you're always building for a world that doesn't exist yet. It didn't stop Leland Stanford. That determination to take a tract of farmland in a sparsely settled state and insist it become a world-renowned center of learning has been part of Silicon Valley's DNA from the start.
Originally published at LinkedIn.